Craft Butchered Meats
We Proudly Offer a Diverse Selection of Locally Sourced Meats, All From Trusted Farms Right Here in New York State.  In Addition To Providing Premium Meats, We Support Local Farmers With Expert Butcher Services, Turning Your Livestock Into Expertly Crafted Cuts Of Meat.  
View Our Selection
438825631 414706831514078 1902115020566451610 n

Welcome to New York's
Butcher Brothers LLC
Premier Butcher Shop in Cooperstown, NY

At New York's Butcher Bros LLC, we take pride in bringing you the finest, freshest, and most ethically sourced meats from local farms. Our commitment to quality starts with partnering with trusted farmers who prioritize humane practices and sustainable methods.
When you choose us, you're not just getting premium cuts of meat—you’re supporting local agriculture and ensuring that every meal you prepare is crafted with care and integrity. From tender steaks to handcrafted sausages and everything in between, our expertly curated selection is designed to meet the needs of every home cook, grill master, and culinary enthusiast.
Visit us today and experience the difference that truly local, responsibly sourced meat can make. Your table deserves nothing less.
Your Community Butcher | Locally Sourced. Expertly Crafted.

LOCATION

12 Commons Drive
Cooperstown, NY 13326

HOURS

Monday - Friday: 10:00am - 6:00pm
Saturday: 10:00am - 5:00pm
Sunday: Closed

CONTACT

Featured Specials


 
Turkey
Whole Turkey
Bring the taste of local farms to your holiday table! Our whole turkeys are carefully sourced from nearby farms, ensuring freshness, flavor, and quality you can trust. Perfect for roasting, sharing, and making every meal memorable
$5.75 per lb.
Golden chicken pot pie delight

Chicken or Ham Pot Pies

A holiday favorite!  Our Chicken and Ham Pot Pies are a savory, soul-warming classic that combines tender chunks of chicken or smoky ham in a rich, creamy sauce, all tucked beneath a golden, flaky pastry crust. It’s the ultimate comfort food—perfectly balancing flavor, texture, and heartiness in every bite.
$14.99 per pie
Rabbit
Rabbit
Discover the rich, tender flavor of farm-raised rabbit — a lean and healthy alternative to traditional meats. Perfect for stews, roasts, or grilling, our rabbit is locally sourced and expertly prepared for premium freshness. Taste the quality that sets our butcher shop apart.
Loin & Bacon $24.99 per lb.
Wings & Leg Quarters $19.99 per lb.
Charcuterie board
Charcuterie Board
New to the menu!  Elevate any gathering with our artisan charcuterie boards, perfectly curated for flavor, variety, and visual appeal.  Featuring 12 ounces of parmesan, asiago and provolone cheeses, 8 ounces of dried Italian sausage and 2 ounces of gourmet jam. Our charcuterie boards turn any occasion into a memorable experience to indulge, share, and savor every bite.
$24.99 per Board
Bottom Round & Stew
Perfect for hearty family meals, our locally sourced stew meat and bottom round roast deliver rich flavor and tenderness in every bite. Ideal for slow-cooking or roasting, they’re your go-to cuts for comforting, home-cooked goodness.
$8.99 per lb.
Chuck Roast or Steaks
Chuck roasts and steaks are prized for their robust beefy flavor, generous marbling, and versatility in both slow-cooked and grilled dishes. Whether you're preparing a classic pot roast or searing a steak for hearty comfort food, this cut delivers tenderness and rich taste when cooked right.
$10.99 per lb.
Butcher edge2

Find Out What Makes Us Stand Out
Discover why so many of your neighbors love New York's Butcher Brothers LLC.
 

★★★★★

"Make this butcher your first stop! Their hamburger is pure beefy bliss, the short ribs are legendary, and the NY strip/ribeyes? Melt-in-your-mouth perfection. Don't miss this hidden gem – your tastebuds will thank you!"
~ Amber K.

★★★★★

"What a hidden gem of a place. You just can’t find this high quality meat anywhere near here. Had a beef tenderloin roast for Christmas and everyone raved about it, the rib eyes are excellent and everything else, including cheese curds and other delicious bites they sell. All NYS raised and the prices are excellent for such quality and service! These guys know what they’re doing."

~ Mary T.

★★★★★

"Tried the Irish bangers. They were awesome!"

~ Rob G.
Butcher edge2a

Call Ahead To Place Your Pick Up Order

Contact Us
Steak 55e6d1434f 1920
470187550 582786764706083 5692130105148190737 n
451764396 472819059036188 5328139573258914608 n